Make Every Interview Count: 9 Ways to Assess Role Fit

Adam Wood, CCO of Orthocell, shares nine ways to best assess role fit when interviewing candidates


Over the years, I’ve had the opportunity to interview candidates for a variety of positions across a broad range of seniority levels and locations. What I’ve attempted to provide here are some observations on how to interview with the goal of predicting role fit.


The disclaimer is that prediction is notoriously difficult. There’s an argument that your instinct improves over time and interviewing becomes more of an art than a science. For now, I’ll try to take a scientific approach and offer some tips on what has worked for me.


1. Spend 55 minutes defining the problem, and 5 minutes finding the solution

As part of scoping the role, clarify the experience, aptitude and behaviours it requires. What must someone bring on day one? What can you teach, and do you have the time and resources to teach it?


Be equally specific about culture. “A good fit” needs to mean more than someone you get along with, although that matters too. Define the behaviours that matter in your team, such as taking ownership or being willing to challenge a decision. That gives you something concrete to assess.


Working with your internal talent acquisition team or recruitment partner can help clarify your thinking.


2. Tell me a story

I like to ask candidates to talk me through their career story. The choices they explain can be as revealing as the roles themselves. Why did they make a move? What drew them to a particular opportunity? What did they learn?


It also gives you a sense of how they communicate. Can they make their story clear and engaging, judge what is relevant and bring you along with them? I place a lot of weight on communication skills in any role, particularly in sales and marketing, so this is a key question for me.


3. Don’t be predictable

Predictable questions tend to produce predictable answers. Asking someone to “tell me about a time you had to deliver bad news” is unlikely to tell you much because it invites a rehearsed response.


You can make a predictable question more useful by exploring the answer with follow-up questions: “What made that situation difficult?” “What options did you consider?” “What did you do when the first approach didn’t work?” This allows you to assess their critical thinking skills and ability to reflect on an experience.


4. A good question is better than a good answer

I like to allow candidates a reasonable amount of time to ask questions. If they’re squeezed into the last two minutes, you lose a critical part of the interview and give the candidate little opportunity to assess the role.


It can also be useful to allow questions throughout the conversation. What do they want to understand? Do they build on something we’ve discussed? Are they curious about the challenges they would inherit and what success would look like?


The questions they ask can help you understand what matters to them. Another personal disclaimer: I value curiosity when hiring for almost any role, so this matters to me too.


5. Know thyself

One question I find useful is: “What’s the biggest misperception people have of you?” (borrowed from Danny Meyer).


The follow-up matters here too. Why might people form that impression? Is there anything in their behaviour that contributes to it? What have they done to address it? I’m interested in whether someone can consider how they come across and recognise their part in a situation. This is a helpful way to assess their self-awareness and humility, another key attribute for me when hiring.


Be wary of an answer that places all the responsibility on other people.


6. We vs. I

I want people who recognise their team’s contribution, but when every achievement is described as “we”, it can be difficult to understand what the candidate actually did.


I would ask directly: “What were you personally responsible for?” “Which decision was yours?” “What did the other team members contribute?”


You should come away understanding both the collective achievement and the individual’s role in it. The same applies when discussing something that went wrong.


7. Connecting the dots

Listen for patterns across the conversation. Someone may describe enjoying autonomy in one answer, then explain that they struggled when a manager gave them little direction.


That’s worth exploring. You could ask: “Earlier, you said you value independence. How does that connect with the situation you’ve just described?”


Asking candidates to connect their examples helps you understand the conditions in which they work well, how they interpret their experiences and whether their account holds together. I also find that pointing out these connections allows candidates to reflect on their character. This gives you a better sense of who they are and helps with one of the hardest things to assess in an interview: culture fit.


8. What comes naturally

“What are you naturally good at?” can open up a different conversation, particularly when you allow the answer to extend beyond work.


They might be the person friends turn to for advice, someone who enjoys fixing things, or the organiser who gets a group moving. Ask for an example, then bring it back to the role: “Where does that show up in your work?”


This should give you a good sense of the person’s aptitudes, which you can then assess against the role’s criteria. You may also uncover their “unofficial job title”: what they can bring to the team beyond the position description.


9. Bring a different perspective to the conversation

Interviewing alongside a colleague who typically sees situations differently from you can be helpful. They’ll likely notice things you might miss and challenge your assumptions. During the debrief, compare observations before sharing your overall verdict so you can benefit from their independent judgement.


I’ve always had two or three people who played this role in interviews. The key is to identify someone who thinks differently from you. This can help cut through unconscious bias and support a better hiring decision.


In closing

Even after many interviews, great hires and some less successful ones, I still consider myself a student of the hiring process. On reflection, these nine ideas are ways I’ve tested my instincts, challenged my assumptions and gained a clearer sense of the person in front of me.



Whatever your approach, I’d encourage you to stay curious enough to let the candidate change your mind, acknowledge that there will always be an element of judgement, and find your balance between the art and science of hiring.

by Shazamme System User • 13 May 2026
Episode 6: From Ultrasound to Global MedTech Leadership: Growth, Culture & Customer Obsession
by Shazamme System User • 23 April 2026
Episode 5: Pressure, Patients & Leadership: Inside MedTech’s Toughest Moments
View all case studies